India's Test selection dilemma: Under-fire Rishabh Pant and lack of experienced spinners increase headache

A year ago, Pant’s starting spot was never in doubt. He was coming off a stunning 2025 tour of England, where he scored 479 runs at 68.42, including twin hundreds — 134 and 118 — at Headingley. A broken foot at Old Trafford cut that series short, though he heroically returned to the pitch to score a valuable half-century. The returns since have been patchier — a lean IPL saw him step down as Lucknow Super Giants captain, and then he was stripped of the Test vice-captaincy in favour of Rahul ahead of the one-off Test against Afghanistan in June. His stylish 81 betrayed no nerves, but a poor showing of 2 and 28 in the Colombo warm-up has turned the heat up again.

Pant is still, by common consent, one of the side's most important Test batters — chief selector Ajit Agarkar was explicit that the vice-captaincy switch was about experience and workload, not any doubt over Pant's batting. But losing the deputy's tag also strips away some of the protective cover seniority provides. A vice-captain having a lean patch is hard to leave out; a middle-order batter who is simply a name on the sheet is not. The safety net that his reputation provided him is thinner than it was twelve months ago, and there's no recent match-winning knock to lean on if the runs don't come early.

Pant will not be dropped for Galle; his class makes that close to unthinkable. Why then is he in the storm? Because of the adjacent debate his selection raises — Dhruv Jurel at No. 6, and the question of balance. Jurel has spent the past year building a case to be picked as a specialist batter rather than a reserve keeper, with hundreds for India A and a maiden Test century against the West Indies in Ahmedabad last year.

And just last month, he captained India A in Sri Lanka while piling on the runs, scoring a half-century and an unbeaten century in three innings. With Pant keeping wicket, playing Jurel purely as a batter at six adds crucial batting depth. But is that the best solution? After all, it would also mean going into a match that already looks light on wicket-taking threat without a specialist bowling option in that slot.

Handing the gloves to the better batter on form — Jurel — would produce five specialist, reliable batters. Promoting Ravindra Jadeja, one of the best all-rounders in the world, to No. 6, would leave room for an extra bowler. And given the fragility of India’s pace battery, that might be an even greater necessity.

That makes the case for handing debutant Saransh Jain — the right-handed Madhya Pradesh off-spinning all-rounder with 188 first-class wickets and a first-class batting average above 31 — a cap ahead of Suthar. Having skilled right-handers in the lower middle order, in Jain and/or Jurel, would fall in line with coach Gautam Gambhir’s preference for left-right batting partnerships.

It’s a harsh call, yes. Suthar was Player of the Match on his Test debut against Afghanistan in June, taking seven wickets in the match, including a six-for, and has done nothing wrong since. Dropping him after a single Test to accommodate a debutant purely for tactical variety is a tough call to defend. But it would arguably be the most balanced call in these conditions, and Gambhir has long shown himself to be a betting man — look no further than Sudharshan and Karun Nair’s trial-by-fire in England last year.

Prasidh is the more experienced, but form is on Gurnoor’s side. Like Jurel, he played in India A’s unofficial Test v Sri Lanka A last month in Galle — and like Jurel, he performed fabulously, taking a 10-wicket match haul and using his height to trouble the Sri Lankan batters. He can bat too; in the warm-up game, he hit 36 off 18 balls. He would thus be a reassuring tail-ender, much like Siraj, who can attack (as in the warm-up match) and defend (as in England last year) with the bat reliably. But the larger question is of wickets, and that will be the metric he will be judged on.

Any hope of reaching the World Test Championship Final will rest on a clean sweep of Sri Lanka. The spotlight will be as much on the match performances as on the selection calls.

Click here to read article